Research Activities
Enabling Change through Focused Research and Design
The research priorities of this roadmap are patient-centered, outcome-oriented, and solution-agnostic. With private interest and investment from the corporate, philanthropic, and venture capital communities, advances can be made that will have significant positive implications for the global population of people living with kidney diseases.
To advance innovative KRT solutions that can repair or closely replicate the complex functions of kidneys, it is critical to evaluate, understand, and address each function individually. Expand each section below to see the R&D activities, timelines, and recent community progress, including KidneyX recipients.
Activities
Solution Type
Description
Near-Term
(2019-2022)
Mid-Term
(2023-2025)
Long-Term
(2026+)
Develop a size-selective blood filter that is capable of 40L/ day filtrate with minimal or no use of anticoagulants or anti-clotting agents
Identify or generate cell source/type(s)—ideally renewable (although not required)—needed to perform desired barrier and permeability functions, and optimize integrated cellular structures or corresponding cell isolation and differentiation techniques (e.g., production of functional glomerular endothelial cells, mesangial cells, and podocyte cells)
Develop a size-selective, non-clotting blood filter (connected to circulation with or without pump) that is capable of 40L/day filtrate and will freely pass electrolytes and non-protein-bound toxins
Demonstrate cell line phenotype stability and preservation in ex vivo and in vivo systems to allow for stable blood filtration
Demonstrate function in full-scale animal model with residual kidney function (necessity and length of animal studies will be product-specific and may vary)
Demonstrate function in anephric animal models without residual kidney function (necessity and length of animal studies will be product-specific and may vary)
Demonstrate a size-selective, non-clotting filter that is capable of 40L/day filtrate with 12–24 months of continuous performance
Key
Recent Progress
Description
KidneyX
Community Progress
Roadmap Activity
Electrolyte Homeostasis (7)
Normalize and maintain appropriate levels of key components in the blood
Activities
Solution Type
Description
Near-Term
(2019-2022)
Mid-Term
(2023-2025)
Long-Term
(2026+)
Develop a process for passage of filtrate to the engineered structures that will ultimately contain the differentiated cells that maintain electrolyte homeostasis
Develop in-line sensors or point-of-care systems that measure blood and/or effluent electrolytes during KRT treatments to monitor significant variations in blood electrolytes that could lead to symptoms/complications
Generate cells with defined functional characteristics of critical cell types such as:
- Proximal tubule (glucose, phosphorus, amino acids, protein absorption, organic ion secretion, bicarbonate, hydrogen ion secretion)
- Distal tubule (magnesium, chloride, and calcium transport)
- Collecting duct (proton transport)
Engineer matrix materials and scaffolds that will support functional organization and long-term maintenance of the differentiated state of critical cells in vivo
Develop sorbents to augment electrolyte removal
Develop ion-selective membranes with pores or channels capable of selective removal or retention of electrolytes (e.g., sodium, potassium, calcium, magnesium, phosphate) after blood filtration
Demonstrate integrated tubular replacement unit that performs ion transport activities
Key
Recent Progress
Description
KidneyX
Community Progress
Roadmap Activity
Activities
Solution Type
Description
Near-Term
(2019-2022)
Mid-Term
(2023-2025)
Long-Term
(2026+)
Develop sensors to monitor the volume status of various fluid compartments of the patient, allowing for a personalized fluid removal prescription to avoid volume depletion, intradialytic hypotension, and fluid overload
Develop sensors/methods to measure intra-peritoneal volume in PD
Generate cell type on substrate that can carry out reabsorption/secretion and is water permeable
Develop integrated systems to use sensor input to adjust fluid removal by real-time patient adjustment (remote programmable)
Create processes for directing reabsorbed fluid and electrolytes to enter the circulation
Demonstrate ex vivo structure with water transport features and permeability characteristics that will allow for net reabsorption of 90%–95% of filtered volume
Develop integrated systems to use sensor input to adjust fluid removal as part of a closed-loop system
Key
Recent Progress
Description
KidneyX
Community Progress
Roadmap Activity
Activities
Solution Type
Description
Near-Term
(2019-2022)
Mid-Term
(2023-2025)
Long-Term
(2026+)
Generate cell type capable of organic anion/cation transport to secrete selected protein-bound toxins and drugs that are not freely filtered
Develop technology that shifts the dynamic equilibrium of protein binding for toxins further toward a non-bound state, making them filterable
Develop new sorbent devices capable of binding/ adsorbing/metabolizing uremic toxins from dialysate or ultrafiltrate, with minimal removal of vital chemicals
Demonstrate ex vivo structure that exploits filtration and secretion to achieve 70%–90% of normal toxin secretion
Develop oral sorbents capable of binding/adsorbing/ metabolizing uremic toxins to augment toxin removal
Demonstrate toxin removal and secretory functionality of implanted cell-based systems in vivo
Develop "smart" filters, mixed-matrix membranes, or blood sorbents capable of binding/adsorbing uremic toxins
Key
Recent Progress
Description
KidneyX
Community Progress
Roadmap Activity
Activities
Solution Type
Description
Near-Term
(2019-2022)
Mid-Term
(2023-2025)
Long-Term
(2026+)
Develop system for dialysate delivery and removal that is hygienically sound, easy to use, and aesthetically appealing
Develop an exterior filtrate drainage system that is functional, hygienically sound, and aesthetically appealing
Create a highly impermeable conduit (i.e., drainage system from outflow of engineered processing system to exterior, potentially involving the urinary bladder) to move the non-adsorbed/re-adsorbed processed filtrate from the body
Key
Ideal solutions should address multiple or all kidney functions, be easy for health care professionals and those receiving KRT to access and maintain, and facilitate real-time monitoring of the function. Expand each section below to see the R&D activities, timelines, and recent community progress, including KidneyX recipients.
Activities
Solution Type
Description
Near-Term
(2019-2022)
Mid-Term
(2023-2025)
Long-Term
(2026+)
Develop components of the blood circuit that allow for hemodialysis without the need for systemic anticoagulation
Develop PD access with improved drainage characteristics, including prevention of outflow failure
Develop PD access with reduced risk of infection
Develop a safer vascular access capable of preventing (e.g., needle-free) or mitigating (e.g., self-sealing) catastrophic events of a vascular access disconnect
Develop a vascular access with fewer or no interventions needed to maintain patency
Develop methods for early detection/diagnosis of access-related infections
Develop novel biomaterial-based conduit or endothelial cell-lined robust conduit (i.e., stent) that permits delivery of blood to the filtration unit
Develop access that is non-intrusive and functionally acceptable, easy and quick for the patient to connect and disconnect, secure with minimal discomfort (e.g., skin-level or sub-cutaneous access), and aesthetically pleasing to patients
- Hemodialysis (Near-term)
- Wearables (Mid-term)
- PD Access (Near- and mid-term)
Develop entire blood circuit that allows for hemodialysis with minimal or no use of anticoagulants or anti-clotting agents
Develop vascular access with internal connection to the native vasculature that maintains patency without the need for systemic anticoagulation
Develop vascular access that significantly reduces the risk of infection over the life of the implant
Key
Recent Progress
Description
KidneyX
Community Progress
Roadmap Activity
Activities
Solution Type
Description
Near-Term
(2019-2022)
Mid-Term
(2023-2025)
Long-Term
(2026+)
Identify and/or develop potential materials with desired scaffold properties (mechanical, porosity, degradation) for structural support/scaffold development, as well as scaffold manufacturing techniques. In addition, these scaffolds must be biocompatible and porous to allow for movement of reabsorbed fluid and allow ready access for secretion of toxins into the processed filtrate
Develop a scaffold or membrane device capable of allowing oxygenation and nutrient access for transporting epithelial cells and demonstrate activity ex vivo
Develop and demonstrate structural support/scaffold that maintains desired function in vivo
For systems using sorbents, develop new sorbents with fewer adverse electrolyte changes, no generation of potentially toxic byproducts, greater uremic toxin capacity, and ability to be regenerated between uses
Key
Recent Progress
Description
KidneyX
Community Progress
Roadmap Activity
Activities
Solution Type
Description
Near-Term
(2019-2022)
Mid-Term
(2023-2025)
Long-Term
(2026+)
Identify gene modifications needed to address coagulation incompatibilities, antibody-mediated rejection, inflammatory responses, etc., for xenotransplantation
Genetically engineer animal to inactivate viral and pathogenic organisms for xenotransplantation
Identify appropriate genetic modification and immunological characterization pre-screening methods/ regimens, as well as pharmacological interventions, for xenotransplantation from animals to humans
Standardize panel of immune markers to assess tolerance of RRT product (i.e., minimize immune rejection
Generate suitable transgenic donor animals for xenotransplantation
Demonstrate induction of immune tolerance
Demonstrate long-term graft survival in nephrectomized animals
Recruit host vessels to implanted cellular product and demonstrate perfusion of implanted tissue that is sufficient to maintain cell health and physiological functions
Key
Recent Progress
Description
KidneyX
Community Progress
Roadmap Activity
Activities
Solution Type
Description
Near-Term
(2019-2022)
Mid-Term
(2023-2025)
Long-Term
(2026+)
Establish coordinated registry network of real-world safety and efficacy data
Develop technologies to allow real-time treatment monitoring by various sensors (flow, pressure, volume status, electrolytes, etc.) that can be observed/tracked by patients and providers
Develop online sensors (e.g., for ammonia or other uremic toxins or byproducts) to alert users that sorbent cartridges need to be replaced
Identify in vitro surrogate assays or biomarkers for assessing safety and proper functioning of the KRT
Develop sensors that can provide feedback on body fluid volume and blood concentrations of key components (e.g., potassium, sodium, calcium, phosphorus, pH)
Develop technologies that detect a vascular access disconnect and/or act to avoid blood loss in the event of a disconnect (e.g., a sensor that integrates with software to stop the blood pump and put replacement product in safe mode)
Establish criteria for safety testing necessary before and after human trials to guide developers and allow for projections of development timelines
Develop a mechanism to monitor the integrity of the biological product itself (e.g., clotting, when to replace cells)
Develop integrated systems that use sensor input to allow adjustment in real time or as part of a closed-loop system
Develop technologies to detect and proactively mitigate clotting
Develop mechanism to prevent or deal with gases accumulated by the product
Conduct in vivo testing to evaluate safety (e.g., toxicity), integrity, longevity, and tolerance of RRT product
Key
Recent Progress
Description
KidneyX
Community Progress
Roadmap Activity
Activities
Solution Type
Description
Near-Term
(2019-2022)
Mid-Term
(2023-2025)
Long-Term
(2026+)
Develop lightweight rechargeable batteries capable of powering KRT systems
Develop systems that allow for safe, secure, and efficient two-way communication between the product/implant and the operator
Develop miniaturized systems (e.g., sorbents) capable of regenerating spent dialysate
Develop blood/filtrate/dialysate pumps that are miniaturized, low-energy, and hemocompatible
Develop lightweight power source capable of powering KRT systems that can be recharged using wireless energy transfer
Develop miniaturized, efficient systems to generate sterile water for replacement fluid/dialysate generation
Key
Recent Progress
Description
KidneyX
Community Progress
Roadmap Activity
Efforts to ensure a clear pathway to commercialization or implementation of all solutions can facilitate widespread availability and adoption of innovative KRT solutions. Expand each section below to see the R&D activities, timelines, and recent community progress.
Activities
Solution Type
Description
Near-Term
(2019-2022)
Mid-Term
(2023-2025)
Long-Term
(2026+)
Inform how current standards and regulatory recommendations (e.g., existing guidance documents) can be applied to novel KRT technology, and develop stakeholder working groups to address and publish findings on any identified gaps in testing recommendations (after review of existing standards and guidance)
Review existing literature and publish findings on best practices for animal models and animal studies used for testing KRT systems
Clarify the different regulatory pathways for device-only systems, cellular/device combination systems, and cell- based/xenotransplantation products
Increase understanding and awareness of 1) communication mechanisms (e.g., Pre-Submission, INTERACT) that enable developers to obtain early, non-binding, regulatory advice from the US Food & Drug Administration, and 2) expedited programs intended to facilitate development and review of eligible KRT products
Develop sources of real-world data (e.g., patient registries) that could be used both to help objectively measure iterative improvements in evolving technologies, as well as garner information to support regulatory decision-making
Inform the most appropriate clinical trial designs (including randomized trials and data generation and management) to support product development, safety, approval, coverage, and reimbursement
Qualify and make publicly available Medical Device Development Tools (MDDTs) that can be used by the community to streamline device development and regulatory evaluation33
Key
Recent Progress
Description
KidneyX
Community Progress
Roadmap Activity
KHI's Guide to Regulatory Resources for the Product Developer intends to increase the awareness and understanding of:
- FDA Centers and the products they review
- Communication mechanisms for developers to obtain advice from the FDA
- Available programs to facilitate development and review of eligible KRT products
Activities
Solution Type
Description
Near-Term
(2019-2022)
Mid-Term
(2023-2025)
Long-Term
(2026+)
Develop uniform technology licensing agreement to broaden participation and facilitate collaboration, while allowing contributors to maintain intellectual property rights
Develop and provide a pre-competitive forum for annual scientific exchange, networking, sharing, and collaboration
Assess scientific advancement and facilitate regular updates to the technology roadmap
Identify gaps and develop necessary educational and scientific tools that may assist innovators with non-nephrology backgrounds to accelerate translation of current technology
Develop and maintain a catalog of research and technology advancements to accelerate efficient and coordinated technology development
Facilitate dialogue with parties that have KRT innovation financing models in place and co-investments from foundations, patient associations, payers, and governments to identify and implement best practices
Conduct thorough assessment of existing and in-development KRT systems and associated technology readiness levels (TRLs) to set a baseline for innovation
Identify potential changes to the current Medicare ESRD Prospective Payment System model that could encourage KRT investment and innovation
Key
Recent Progress
Description
KidneyX
Community Progress
Roadmap Activity
Progress and Advances in KRT
Since this roadmap was first published in 2018, there has been incremental progress in advancements of innovative KRT to help achieve an improved patient quality of life. Several noteworthy advances include:
- The roadmap has served as the driving framework for the KidneyX prize competitions, which have resulted in funding for more than 60 innovative solutions for treating kidney disease, including 25 Patient Innovator Challenge award recipients.
- As a supplement to the KRT Roadmap, KHI is undertaking an effort that will measure artificial kidney solution concepts against patient centered design criteria. Those criteria are developed by identifying the problems and needs most important to people with kidney diseases and translating them into design criteria for product developers.
- CMS has developed new policies and models that promote greater access to home dialysis and encourage the development of new and innovative home dialysis machines.34
- The COVID-19 pandemic highlighted an important advantage of home dialysis in a setting where quarantine is required.
- The results of a 2020 study that compiled expert opinions on candidate technologies for future KRTs found that the experts believe that KRT can be significantly improved by innovations categorized in the roadmap, and they expect revolutionary changes before 2040.35
However, the COVID-19 pandemic and its unprecedented impacts inordinately affected the KRT community, causing it to focus its energy and resources primarily on responding to the crisis and kidney patients in need.
But, as programs and initiatives such as KidneyX's Artificial Kidney Prize and the momentum behind other federal government policy initiatives demonstrate, the priorities outlined in the roadmap continue to be of paramount importance to the community.
A Living Roadmap
Additionally, this more broadly accessible digital version of the roadmap—launched in 2022—now truly embodies the "living document" envisioned by the 2018 release. This site can and will be adjusted to reflect the changing needs and consensus of an ever-expanding group of KRT stakeholders, reaffirming the commitment to achieving the improved quality of life that those with kidney failure demand and deserve.